CustomeRules – A Marketing Blog from BI|Digital Marketing


Worst Practices: Email Marketing
January 6, 2010, 8:20 pm
Filed under: Business Models | Tags: , , ,

Here’s a thought: when companies ask if the customer wants to unsubscribe from unwanted email solicitation, they should honor that request, or they shouldn’t ask. Very often they do not but are merely complying with the CAN-SPAM Act of 2003. In many cases by unsubscribing we are merely validating our email addresses for distribution to more spam lists.

It would seem this should be a matter of proper social etiquette — especially for a company that is in the social etiquette business.

Such is the case with FTD.com, a company that sells flowers online. I made the mistake of ordering flowers a year ago for a wedding anniversary, which at the time seemed like a very convenient way to buy a dozen roses. The purchase experience was easy enough and the flowers arrived on time, but soon after the emails started arriving, with weekly offers on specials for floral arrangements but without any particular occasion or triggered event. At the time of purchase I checked the box indicating I did not want to receive future email updates or offers, but they came anyway.

Every time I received one of these emails I clicked the “unsubscribe” link yet they kept coming on a regular basis.

What FTD did was take a favorable customer experience and turn it into a negative, and as we know, a negative customer experience has far more lasting and impactful ramifications. Not only will I never buy anything from FTD online again, I’m sharing my negative experience with others. This would not be effective marketing.

This brings me to the company that has been sending me unsolicited emails for the past couple of months. They are trying to get me to sign up for a webinar about best practices for email marketing and the risk of spamming, with no option to unsubscribe. I’m not getting this.


5 Comments so far
Leave a comment

“…webinar about best practices for email marketing and the risk of spamming, with no option to unsubscribe” – oh, the irony ;)

My guess is that some companies do that on purpose. I have a feeling they are aware of the potential negative impact but are doing it anyway to build up their subscribers database to allow them to do other things. Perhaps they can then sell it, rent it or their end-of-year bonus depends on the number of subscribers so they are trying to keep it on a certain level. I know that blog banner cost is determined by how many visitors and how many subscribers this particular blog has. Could be a similar approach with FTD – get your money now and figure out what happens in the future when it happens.

Comment by Alex

Probably so Alex, in which case I guess we just have to open a junk email account for online purchases, but it just ain’t right…

Comment by Mike Nelson

I guess junk email, while invasive, isn’t quite as environmentally destructive as the bible of Champion catalogs I get every month. I haven’t run for ages and its been even longer since I bought something from them….

Comment by jeffstender

From the environmental perspective perhaps it’s less destructive, but from the behavioral perspective e-mail surprisingly falls into a more intrusive medium. I could be wrong but e-mail belongs to Personal zone (around 4 ft) vs. Social zone for the mail (around 20 ft). Mobile world is even more sensitive as it lives in the Intimate zone, then there’s the cost issue too but it’s a different story.

Comment by Alex

I agree with much of what you’re saying, so for the sake of arguing a point, do you think it’s a behavioral thing? We’re pretty conditioned to go through our mail when we get home and quickly create “keep” or “recycle” piles. Webmail providers are trying to make this easier by filtering on our behalf, but technology isn’t a catch-all safety net. Maybe it’s our perception than needs to be re-calibrated. Quite frankly, with such pressure on environmental codes of conduct, brand reputations are going to be tarnished no matter how they deliver their junk.

Comment by jeffstender




Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>